Though mastering a craft may be a feat for the ages, a drawn-out process involving hours upon hours of hard work, blood, sweat, tears and a whole lot of valuable mistakes, there is something much trickier than putting in your 10,000 hours: Actually knowing what to do with it.

Taste, even more so than skill, is extremely hard to come by, just ask the fine posters on Reddit page r/ATBGE — a.k.a “awful taste but great execution.”

From a delicious, nutritious, and very layered ‘Shrekfast’ to the long-awaited answer of what would happen if a deep-sea blob fish made a wish to become a real Supra, here are some times horrible ideas were executed impressively well.